December 14, 2004

Weblog Awards and Defining 'Blogger'

The votes are in and the 2004 Weblog Awards race is over. Congrats to Ace of Spades Headquarters, the only blog endorsed by me to win. So much for the crucial Rusty Shackleford endorsement.....

I have one bone to pick. I am pretty pissed about NRO's Kerry Spot winning for Best New Blog. Geraghty runs a great internet site, but it's not a blog. A blogger, by definition, doesn't have a boss. He might get paid through advertisements or donations, but he doesn't fill out a W-2. Geraghty is a columnist, Bill Ardolino is a blogger.

Kudos to Kevin Aylward who did his best to vet the process. I guess I'm partially to blame for some of the undeserving nominees making the final cut--I had promised him I'd help with the awards and then sort of cheesed out. Sorry, finals take a lot out of a guy. I had to decide whether to help with the awards or keep blogging. I chose the latter.

In the future, though, let's make sure blog awards go to, you know, bloggers. Not everyone who has a website is a blogger. Not everyone who writes online is a blogger. Bloggers are a community of the unprofessional. We are the pajamahadin. We are media entrepreneurs. We are what democracy looks like. We are the voice of the people.

We need to come up with a better definition for 'blog' and 'blogger'.

Ok, end pontification.

It was enough for me to make the final cut for Best New Blog of 2004. Thanks for the many endorsements--I lost track of them a day or so after the voting began. Shout out to all of you who didn't vote for me as instructed. Some props, too, for the homies who gave me their own awards. For instance, I received an award for Best Blog By A College Professor Who Can't Spell While Live Blogging During A Final Exam (in your face Llama Butchers) and one for Blogger most likely to appear under the headline 'Man Kills 5, Shoots Self' (update: read that one wrong earlier---I'm much happier with this one!!). I gladly accept those awards and thank all the little people that made this great occasion possible.....

Posted by: Rusty at 12:34 PM | Comments (11) | Add Comment
Post contains 379 words, total size 3 kb.

1 We are the pajamahadin. Ironic, isn't it, considering Geraghty was the first recorded instance of "pajamahadeen". This does not mean I disagree with you. Geraghty is good, but is he a blogger? And more importantly, does anyone care?

Posted by: Editor at December 14, 2004 12:39 PM (adpJH)

2 I"m afraid that you didn't quite pick up the right award statue from sortapundit. He actually named you the "Blogger most likely to appear under the headline 'Man Kills 5, Shoots Self'" and not the kind gay one. That's not quite so good, I don't think...

Posted by: Jimmie at December 14, 2004 12:46 PM (LIkgw)

3 Jimmie's right, Rustmeister. I mean it in a good way, though. You're a little, er, unbalanced - but funny with it. P.S. Frank J wants that gay statue back.

Posted by: sortapundit at December 14, 2004 01:04 PM (SgQqe)

4 On the contrary, that is a blog. A corporation can have a blog and it's still a blog. However, Best of the Web Today, while wonderful, is a column, not a blog. It shouldn't have been a nominee, never mind a winner. Nor should it and other non-blogs ever be in the Ecosystem.

Posted by: Jay at December 14, 2004 01:59 PM (7RCzM)

5 Hm. There are a lot of people out there who are being paid to blog, but none of them are right-of-center. That said, there is something vaguely oxymoronic about calling something a "blog" that is part of an established media website. And something a little weird about the Kerry Spot still being a web presence anyway. Election's over, you know? The Best of the Web thing is a little the the Drudge Report thing: they both seem to be to be blog precursors. Taranto once called his thang a "bloglike column," and I liked that. Personally, I'd love to be paid to blog, even if it meant that you'd never regard me as a True Blog again. I'll bet my husband would like it, too.

Posted by: Attila Girl at December 14, 2004 02:18 PM (SuJa4)

6 Jay, I just don't see it that way. It's like calling the Dallas Cowboys a great college football team. And I'm not knocking Geraghty, he's great, he's just not a blogger.

Posted by: Rusty at December 14, 2004 02:36 PM (JQjhA)

7 Exactly Beth.

Posted by: Rusty at December 14, 2004 05:13 PM (JQjhA)

8 Rusty, I think that's exactly what Jay was saying - the winner should not even have been on the list, should never have won because it's not a real blog nor is it done by a blogger under "Best of the Web." Either I'm mistaken but you both said the same thing, just differently. I know, happens all the time. And Rusty, I did vote for you!! Couldn't vote for you Jay because I couldn't find your name anywhere; maybe next year will be different and like the llamas, you'll have a partnership on a blog. (hint) You're both great as far as I'm concerned. Cindy

Posted by: firstbrokenangel at December 18, 2004 10:56 PM (D39Vm)

9 By the way, it's good to see you out and about, Jay. Cindy

Posted by: firstbrokenangel at December 18, 2004 10:58 PM (D39Vm)

10 I agree Rusty but doubt that'll happen. The TV calls us "pundits."

Posted by: firstbrokenangel at December 19, 2004 12:20 AM (D39Vm)

11 ok, I saw Michelle Malkin as a guest on FOX. They said she was a "syndicated columnest" not a blogger, so when it comes to blogging, she can't count. Cindy

Posted by: firstbrokenangel at December 24, 2004 01:53 AM (D39Vm)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
22kb generated in CPU 0.0374, elapsed 0.1825 seconds.
118 queries taking 0.1599 seconds, 255 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.