January 12, 2005

Shia vs. Sunni Fatwas

A fatwa is an Islamic religious ruling. In my absence Jeff at Beautiful Attrocities has been parousing the Ask the Imam site. The Ask the Imam site is obviously run by those crumudgeonly Sunnis. For instance:

Q: What are the positions allowed for intercourse? Can wife sit on top of husband?

A: An Aayat of the noble Qur'aan states, 'Have sexual relations with your wives in any manner as long as it is in the front opening & not in the hind opening.'

But those Shia are a bunch of swingers, baby. Check this out from the Grand Ayatollah Sistani's site which Tim Worstall reminded me of:
Question: My question is, what does the holy book Quran and prophet Mohammad (pbuh) say about anal sex even if the wife agrees to experience this with her husband?

Answer: As deduced from narration anal sex is permissible; but it is strongly undesirable. Permission is bound to wifeÂ’s agreement and consent to anal sex. If she is not consenting, it would be impermissible.

Oh, and just in case you were wondering, it's official--Bill Clinton is a Shia Muslim. How do I know? (Hint: Zina means adultery)
Question:What is the definition of Zina?

Answer:Zina does not take place without penetration.

See, he really didn't have sexual relations with that woman!!

Anyway, I don't know why Iowahawk felt like he needed to spice the answers up. I mean, you have to admit that's some funny stuff left alone. As usual, though, Iowahawk does the improbable and makes the funny funnier:

Q: I look like a famous person in England called David Baddiel (he is a comedian). People call me Dave all the time. It is really annoying & depressing. I don't understand why Allah would give me this curse.

A: Remind the people around you that you are not a kafir & you are a Muslim faithful to your Deen. Also, cut off the kafir comedian's head, as this will reduce your confusing resemblance.

PS-A not so funny fatwa from Ask the Imam:

You should understand that we as Muslims firmly believe that the person who doesn't believe in Allah as he is required to, is a disbeliever who would be doomed to Hell eternally. Thus one of the primary responsibilities of the Muslim ruler is to spread Islam throughout the world, thus saving people from eternal damnation.

Thus what is meant by the passage in Tafsir Uthmani, is that if a country doesn't allow the propagation of Islam to its inhabitants in a suitable manner or creates hindrances to this, then the Muslim ruler would be justifying in waging Jihad against this country, so that the message of Islam can reach its inhabitants, thus saving them from the Fire of Jahannum. If the Kuffaar allow us to spread Islam peacefully, then we would not wage Jihad against them.

And then there's the old bait and switch:
Q: I was shocked recently when I heard of the news that an American was beheaded by some Iraqis and this was shown on video to the whole world!! I just couldn`t digest it that a live human was slaughtered like an animal in front of the whole world!! This would certainly damage the already deterioting position of Islam in front of the west. It reminded me of a similar case of Daniel Pearl`s murder in Pakistan about 2 years back. This is really disturbing to see Muslims doing such acts of violence. I agree that the people of Iraq are also suffering at the hands of the invaders and the resistance they are lodging against them is legitimate but I don`t think that Islam permits this kind of violence. What do you say about it.

A: The incident that you have written about is indeed shocking. However, it is extremely important that we do not lose hold of the bigger picture because of our emotions. DoesnÂ’t it seem strange that throughout the Iraqi war and so many months of oppressive occupation, it is only when the US army has come under fire from the entire world because of their gross indifference to humanity that only now the Iraqis decide to publicly execute an American?

Yup, the terrorists exercise a lot of restraint. Another reason why the Abu Ghraib photos should have never been publicly released.

Posted by: Rusty at 12:00 PM | Comments (4) | Add Comment
Post contains 715 words, total size 5 kb.

1 What is the Islam position on the relationship between the wife and husband? If husband request that she stimulate him by inserting her finger in his anus. http://www.islamweb.net/ver2/Istisharat/ShowFatwa.php?lang=E&Id=8026&Option=FatwaId

Posted by: EvilTHelL at January 13, 2005 04:46 AM (YJx7q)

2 Whilst much of current planning in Iraq seems to place great store on the result of the elections, one can easily envisage the elections having to be postponed, or their results, should they go ahead on time, being anything but helpful. It is hard to imagine what assurances the Shia (majority) community can give to the Sunnis to ensure their active participation in the democratic process. Should the Sunnis boycott the elections it will be impossible to claim the results as meaningful. Bearing in mind that Iraq has no experience of being governed as a single, democratic country, and that most Iraqis' loyalties are to their tribal, ethnic and religious leaders, would it not be better to prepare now for alternatives should the result of the elections prove unhelpful? The most obvious solution is a federation. With autonomy granted to the Kurds, Sunnis and Shias within a federal structure, many of the current rivalries and insecurities would be lessened. A federal Iraq is less likely to be a danger to its neighbours and, with a constitution guaranteeing minority rights backed by the UN, there would be a reasonable chance of an end to the current violence. This in turn would hasten the date for the withdrawal of coalition forces, to everyone's advantage. Obviously, there would be many difficulties to overcome on the ground, such as ownership of the oil fields (Although paying 80 per cent of oil royalties to an independent Iraq development board, as practised in pre-1958 days, could be a solution.) A federation would, surely, be a great improvement on the all-too-likely result of pursuing current policies.

Posted by: LiquidSnake at January 13, 2005 10:44 AM (PM/BC)

3 Asalam alakom I am writing this e-mail on the behalf of my friend. She is very shy and doesnÂ’t want to be mentioned. As a name so I decided to help her, as she is very upset and feeling very down. I wish if this is possible if this e-mail can be dealt with in confidentiality. My friend has always being a good Shia Muslim girl. She was all the time practising her role as a Muslim girl and wearÂ’s the hejab too. She is from an Arab origin, but currently living in the United Kingdom. She had many marriage proposals from family back in her country. But her parents kept rejecting for no valid reason. So as the girl got a little older, she has to move from her parents house as she started university. The girl had many men asking to marry her again but every time she wanted to give one a chance her parents rejected. They wanted a man from there original country who is well of and not from the family. I think personally that very difficult if the girl is living in the uk ! how will anyone see her ? who will propose? So the girl was met a man who is a Muslim but not shia, from a different nationality and culture. She felt and still feelÂ’s this is the right man for her. The problem is she was dating him and had a very close relationship with him (just like a married couple). She introduced the man to her family but as usual and expected they refused. She knew what she was doing is wrong, but she doesnÂ’t know what to do now! Our sister needs help! She has being to the hospital so many times, because she is very depressed. She feelÂ’s she canÂ’t have a halall life like all other humans. She is asking for advice what should she do? Should she leave the man? Or should she marry him anyway?, can she marry him without her parents acceptance? ,Because her parents are not agreeing for no valid reason? The manÂ’s family are accepting everything , they are welling to take care of the wedding. But the girl is afraid , because both of her parents are not well!. Please can I have the reply to my e-mail address and I will pass the reply to her. I feel very bad for the girl because she is feeling so bad is going to go crazy. She doesnÂ’t want to upset her parents yet she doesnÂ’t want to lose the man who is welling to marry her ! We appreciate very much if we have a reply as soon as possible, because the girl wants to sort her life out and seek forgiveness from Allah. Also what can she do to seek forgiveness from Allah for doing the mistakes that she did do? Kind regards M.A

Posted by: M.A at June 14, 2005 08:53 AM (R1adb)

4 Assalaam o alaykum, I have the same problem as described above, but I am the boy, and the girl I know has lots of problems at home. We both want to put the things right we did wrong in a legitimate manner. Can you please tell me what to do next?

Posted by: KB at August 18, 2005 02:24 PM (Plu4K)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
25kb generated in CPU 0.6025, elapsed 0.5582 seconds.
119 queries taking 0.5443 seconds, 253 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.