January 07, 2005

Five Embedded Reporters Sent Packing

Five embedded broadcasters have been sent packing from Iraq due to a breech in security, most likely involving showing something the enemy could use against the United States and Coallition forces.

NEW YORK As Iraq moves closer to its first democratic elections later this month, the number of news organizations requesting embedded slots with military units there is on the rise, according to officials. But those new embeds better watch their step. E&P has learned that five journalists have been kicked out of embed slots in the past three months for reporting secure information.

"They were all for operational security reasons, (revealing) something that would have been of use to the enemy," Maj. Kris Meyle, who runs the embed program, told E&P from Baghdad this morning. "Generally, it gets done very quickly. Usually it was something that was not done intentionally by the reporter."


There can be a fine line between reporting what can be considered comprimising coverage versus not newsworty coverage. It is strictly a judgement call and one these five journalists aparently made wrong, though it is extremely doubtful it was on purpose.

With the five covering the Baghdad area, there should have been plenty of action and plenty of stories any one of them could cover that would not comprimise security. What about covering the hopes and dreams of the Iraqis? There has still yet to be a solid news story on how the lives of Iraqis have changed since the topple of Saddam Hussein other than the normal lack of electricity and anti-occupation route. I would be willing to bet even those who haven't had electricity in days and hate American soldiers have new found hopes for their own lives they would love to share.

As I've stated before on this site, one journalistic staple is that interviewees, just like everyone else, love to talk about themselves. A reporter interviewing an Iraqi citizen to find out what new hopes and dreams that he or she has now would in no way be a security concern or breech.

One of the more famous cases of an embedded reporter jeopardizing U.S. soldiers during the war in Iraq was that of Fox News anchor Geraldo Rivera who drew a diagram of sorts in the sand with exact troop positions. Rivera was not asked to leave the country or the embedded program therefore what these five did might have been worse.

I would still maintain whatever these five did was better than this reporter, who just "happened" to be at the scene of an execution.

Hat tip: Captain's Quarters

Cross-posted at In the Bullpen

Posted by: Chad at 02:12 PM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 444 words, total size 3 kb.

1 It is time that some of those "news makers" were sent home. News reporters are OK but those with agenda are not!

Posted by: Rod Stanton at January 07, 2005 05:04 PM (tHUgl)

2 I heard Rivera was ordered to leave by military. You sure?

Posted by: greyrooster at January 07, 2005 07:16 PM (ccnRW)

3 By the way. The only people I trust less than lawyers are reporters. They will sell their souls or anything else they have for a story.

Posted by: greyrooster at January 07, 2005 07:18 PM (ccnRW)

4 Look, this is getting me really depressed... not because it goes on, but because no one ever makes any suggestions about what might be done about it. I'm just tired of hearing about the sort of poor judgment that gives a reporting edge to jihadists, and I wonder why I need to even argue that this is the equivalent of aiding and abetting child molesters. The fact is that it's happening because the good guys haven't mounted an effective media campaign that shames them out of it, or that imposed the sort of penalties that media organizations and reporters would pay attention to, like firings and loss of revenue. I'm sorry, but I'm just overdosed on this. Can't take it any more.

Posted by: Demosophist at January 08, 2005 07:44 AM (7AGFb)

5 When these vultures fly where their not suppost to its time to send them home they are risking thier lives for nothing and they should stop acting so foolish and well its time to send CNN packing as well

Posted by: sandpiper at January 08, 2005 08:28 AM (eGPkR)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
20kb generated in CPU 0.0899, elapsed 0.1874 seconds.
119 queries taking 0.1787 seconds, 254 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.