March 17, 2005

Congress Works to Outlaw 132nd Trimester Abortions; Michael Schiavo's Lawyers to Appeal

The United States Congress frantically continues working to reconcile two ultra-late-term abortion bills before Congressmen go home for the Easter holidays. The Jawa Report's Washington bureau chief, Dale Gribble, has been following the legislation.

The Senate has a narrowly focused bill that deals only with the planned abortion of Terri Schiavo, allowing her standing in federal court, which would immediately stay a Florida court's ruling which would allow Planned Parenthood's Boca Raton office to perform the controversial abortion procedure, now scheduled for March 18.

The House, however, passed a more broadly defined bill on Wednesday night. In it, "persons" — defined as "any born individual who is presently outside the womb and in at least the 50th trimester of life" — are given the right to take their case to federal court after the state court route has been exhausted. The House bill does not grant an automatic stay for Schiavo despite support from House leaders like the ultra-conservative Rep. Tom DeLay, the House Majority Leader.

But even with an agreement between the Senate and House, sources told The Jawa Report on Thursday that Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) has "dug in" against passage of the Senate bill by unanimous consent. He is a well-known pro-choice advocate and in a recent press statement said that,

Michael Schiavo has a right to terminate his wife's life. His wife's body belongs to him. What he does with Terri's body is nobody elses busines.
Wyden then added in a press-conference on the steps of Capital Hill,
My personal view is that 132nd trimester abortions are wrong. However, I believe that such decisions are best left to a couple and their doctor.
Wyden's stance could force the Senate to move to cut off debate, setting up a process that could give Wyden and possibly other Democrats, like Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), an opportunity to express their opposition. However, other Democrats oppose letting Schiavo's case end at the state court.

Sen. Rick Santorum (R-PA) has said he will hold up adjournment of the Senate for Easter recess, scheduled to begin Friday and last two weeks, until a vote is taken on this bill. Santorum is a staunch ultra-late-term abortion opponent and is strongly against aborting Terri Schiavo. Santorum's opposition to abortions has been termed "radical" by many moderates because of his support for a Constitutional Amendment which would ban all abortions after the 25th trimester.

The debate comes as Schiavo's parents appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, and Florida Circuit Court Judge George Greer scheduled a hearing Thursday to consider a request from the state to halt the abortion. Judge Greer, in a related case, ruled that the Pope should be removed from life support because people in a vegetative state--even when such vegatables can 'laugh', 'pray', and 'bless the masses'--serve no useful social function.

Florida's Legislature is also taking action similar to that of Congress. A similar state law passed in 2003 was later declared unconstitutional by the Florida Supreme Court. The Florida Supreme Court, citing Roe v. Wade, had claimed that:

among the penumbra of rights gauranteed in the US Constitution was the right to abort spouses at any time during the first 200 trimesters of life.
"However," said the majority opinion, "the state may pass such laws deemed necessary to protect the welfare of society after that time, provided such laws are narrowly taylored and do not impede the doctor-patient-patient's wife relationship."

Schiavo, 41, has been at the center of a long and bitter court battle between her parents and her husband, who wants to have the ultra-late-term abortion performed.

In a press-release from the White House today, President Bush said:

The case of Terri Schiavo raises complex issues. Yet in instances like this one, where there are serious questions and substantial doubts, our society, our laws, and our courts should have a presumption in favor of life. Those who live at the mercy of others deserve our special care and concern. It should be our goal as a nation to build a culture of life, where all Americans are valued, welcomed, and protected and that culture of life must extend even those in the 132nd trimester of life.
Actor and pro-life advocate Mel Gibson added the fuel to the fire to keep ultra-late-term abortion illegal when he sent the following fax to the parents of Terri Schiavo:
I fully support the efforts of Mr. & Mrs. Schindler [Terri's parents] to save the life of their daughter, from a cruel starvation.

Terri's husband should relinquish his right to an abortion and turn the 132nd trimester fetus over to the Schindler's care.

The outlook of 'Terri's Law' was in seriuos jeapordy as the House and Senate could not agree on the scope of the bill. Anticipating the delay, attorney's for the Schindler family have filed an emergency appeal to the US Supreme Court asking for an injunctive stay on the Florida Court's ruling.

George Felos, Michael SchiavoÂ’s lead attorney, filed an immediate response to the motion. NARAL Pro-Choice America and Planned Parenthood also filed an amicus curae brief in support of Michael Schiavo's right to an ultra-late-term abortion.

"Trying to outlaw Mr. Schiavo's clear Constitutional right to do what he pleases with his wife's body is an outrageous attempt by Congress to interfere with the workings of the judicial branch," said NARAL spokesperson Evelyn Becker in a written press-release. "Today the right-wing ideologues are trying to take away Mr. Schiavo's right to a 132nd trimester abortion. If they succeed, then this country may well be on its way back to the days when 132nd term abortions were performed by unlicensed doctors in back alleys under unsanitary conditions, contraceptives were outlawed, homosexuals were rounded up, and negros were forced to ride in the back of the bus."

UPDATE: House to meet in morning to vote on ultra-late-term abortion bill, over Nancy Pelosi's (D-CA) objections.

UPDATE II: Related from Scrappleface

Posted by: Rusty at 06:59 PM | Comments (13) | Add Comment
Post contains 997 words, total size 8 kb.

1 Thanks, I need that comedic break!

Posted by: Eric at March 17, 2005 08:12 PM (lK7Sh)

2 Rusty: Is this starting to get to you? Need a break? Take it.

Posted by: greyrooster at March 17, 2005 10:26 PM (CBNGy)

3 Perhaps if it were someone you loved, who's live hung in the balance, it wouldn't seem so "funny" to you. If you need a break, get out and go for a walk. Making fun of a tragic situation isn't funny. Most Sincerely, Kathy

Posted by: Kathy at March 17, 2005 10:33 PM (kfUgS)

4 Brilliant satire, Rusty! Just brilliant!

Posted by: David C at March 17, 2005 11:24 PM (aOdhJ)

5 So terribly awful and so terribly telling of gross incompetence and negligence it has taken this long and it has come to this... There are so many who should be hanging their heads in SHAME...Your post is taken and understood as it was meant...

Posted by: Crystal Clear at March 18, 2005 02:18 AM (E5Eyf)

6 Excellent Rusty ... You are so right that our Government needs to stop this ridicules habit called dying all togeather. The national fear that someone might just ... DIE (AAAAGHHHHHHH!) ... is taking this nation by storm. Do you have a highway that needs repair? Are your VA rights being trampled? Id your aiport security making you Worry? Do you need a lobotomy? Who cares, your congressmen are working to stop you from dying! But dont worry you can do something! Call you government representatives and support them in stopping death! Anyways back in the real world ... the stupid coffee machine just blew coffee all over the place ... crap!

Posted by: Salamander at March 18, 2005 07:19 AM (W2YA6)

7 EXCELLENT! And lotsa linky love, to boot! Kathy, etc-- Don't be offended; satire points out the absurdity of a situation better than straight news, any day. And the death march for Terri truly IS absurd, to say the least. To me, this is a welcome departure from the straight-faced exhortations that I and others have been writing. Thanks, Rusty!

Posted by: Beth at March 18, 2005 07:25 AM (skHgj)

8 Perhaps we should all bribe Michael Schiavo to stop starving and dehydrating his 'wife's body' to death! His 'wife's body' is responsive, breathing, but cannot swallow--she needs help with feeding. Many people that need 'life' support with medicines/oxigen/wheelchairs. We can offer him a wedding and honeymoon to his current live-in and two children! (What will speak to the depraved minds of Michael & his attorney?) Even criminals in prison are protected better than Terry Schiavo from starving and dehydration.

Posted by: Ranebowriter at March 18, 2005 08:48 AM (NGAcn)

9 Kudos to you, Ranebowriter, for your comment.

Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 18, 2005 08:59 AM (x+5JB)

10 If she were a terrorist we wouldn't have this problem. The ACLU would have their own grandmothers feeding her...and yours too. Where's the NOW?

Posted by: Alicia at March 18, 2005 10:36 AM (M7kiy)

11 Kathy: Sometimes those with depth of thought must at times inject humor. To bad you're still on the surface. MOONBAT????????

Posted by: greyrooster at March 19, 2005 09:01 AM (CBNGy)

12 Just pull the plug on Schiavo already. The Schindlers have distorted the story so badly that the public is seething with unjustified, uninformed rage. Facts: 1. Terri's brain was scanned using an MRI. It was found to be liquified. The only parts left intact are her upper spinal cord and cerebellum - which are responsible for reflexes and automatic systems like heartbeat, sleep cycles, and breathing. There is no consciousness there. 2. In the trials, three of Terri's closest friends testified that Michael and they were all told she would not want to live like this. 3. The court-appointed guardian that lived with her says the Schindlers are fabricating everything they say about her responsiveness. 4. The only people who say she responds are: a. The Schindlers, who want the money from her malpractice settlement b. The lawyers for the Schindlers c. Two doctors who are members of pro-life activist groups the Schindlers had hired for them by pro-life activists d. People who watch those heavily cropped videos which are just random behavior from 4 hours of total tape each. For 3.9 hours, Terri wouldn't look at a balloon. Then, for 5 secs, they managed to get the balloon and her head to move together. The Schindler's are in a psychological state of denial. The woman is gone. We pull the plug on people like this every day. It is standard procedure. I kissed my grandfather goodbye in November the same way. He peacefully and painlessly passed after we removed all support once doctors said he was terminal and no longer with us congnitively. This debate must end, because it is all based on a pack of lies spread by the money-grubbing lawyers and activist groups who have inserted themselves into a fight between in laws. Just pull the plug, be done with it, and everyone shut up and go home.

Posted by: 24 at March 21, 2005 02:53 PM (cuTsc)

13 24, You said, "Terri's brain was scanned using an MRI.". Wrong, the implants in her cranium prohibit an MRI. They can be removed, and then an MRI could be done, but no MRI to date. OR PET scan, which I am hearing would be better than an MRI. You may be thinking about a CT scan that was done, and you can find a link to see it for yourself at Codeblueblog.com. The doctor at that site says he has seen ten thousand CTs and that Terri's brain is not that bad.

Posted by: Richard at March 24, 2005 04:26 AM (LMxET)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
31kb generated in CPU 0.0334, elapsed 0.1342 seconds.
119 queries taking 0.1268 seconds, 262 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.