January 14, 2006

The Zawahiri Attack in the Pakistan Press

These are excerpts from Pakistani accounts of the attack, which is now reported by Western news agencies to have resulted in the deaths of five senior al Qaeda members. Most of the Pakistani stories speculate that the attack was targeting Taliban fugitives, and carried out by Coalition aircraft based in Afghanistan.

There is some disagreement from supposed eyewitnesses as to whose houses were hit. Much of the information given to Pakistani news agencies came from a local politico, Haroon ur Rashid, who is a hardline Muslim unsympathetic to the West.

I've added emphasis to what may be indications that al Qaeda bodies were removed, though none of the accounts mention al Qaeda or Zawahiri. I've also highlighted what seem to be disagreements as to which houses were struck. Also, one of these stories contains the only report I've seen of live suspects being detained. The Nation:

According to our correspondent, the incident happened when a village close to the Pak-Afghan border was mysteriously attacked with rockets and missiles. Tribesmen at the joint funeral of the victims said that several gunship US helicopters took part in the well-planned operation which was carried out a few days after Pakistan protested to the US military in Afghanistan over the deaths of another eight people in cross-border firing.
In FridayÂ’s attack, the houses owned by Maulana Muhammad Ismael, Sher Afzal and Bakht Pur Jan were targeted and the Hujras (portions for guests) were badly damaged.
Meanwhile, NWFP Senior Minister Sirajul Haq said that 17 persons were killed and six injured. The minister, who hails from Lower Dir district adjacent to Bajaur Agency, has demanded of the federal government to take notice of the incident and lodge a protest with, what he called, United States forces camping across the border in Kunar province of Afghanistan.
The tribal elders from Khar who attended the joint funeral said that 18 victims had been laid to rest in the village graveyard.
Tribesmen said that a number of bodies had been airlifted from the area while a few persons were also detained and shifted to unknown place.
Maulvi Faqir Muhammad, a local religious figure, who was accused of providing shelter to alleged militants, also attended the funeral besides elders from the area. In May 2005, operations were conducted in Mamund tehsil for nabbing Maulvi Faqir Muhammad but he is still at large.
Pak Tribune:
The bombardment by the Allied forces, fell on Damadola Burkanday area of tehsil Mamoon in Bajaur agency at 3:00 am PST, completely flattening the homes of BakhtPur, Muhammad Rahim and Bacha Khan.

According to local eyewitnesses, fourteen members of BakhtPur family along with four others died, due to indiscriminate bombing. The dead included eight children, and four females. The dead included, 9-year old Nadia Bibi, 10-year old Sadiqa, 9-year old Tayyeb, 7 year old Zahid ullah, 5-year old Hussain Nawaz. Others included 20-year-old Ameer Muhammad, 25-year-old Nazir Muhammad, 50-year Noor Pari, 40-year old Shahi Badan, 30-year-old Qari Saeed, 30-year-old Tahira Bibi, and others. Some of the dead were unidentified.

Pakistan Times:
The eyewitnesses told Geo news that coalition airplanes allegedly flying over the areas since last four days and sound of planes also heard when the explosions occurred.

They suspected of missile strikes or bombardment by these fighter planes have hit the area and caused losses. The witnesses added that the explosions have killed at least 10 people whereas a house of local tribesman Gul Zaman was completely destroyed.

Also posted at The Dread Pundit Bluto.

Posted by: Bluto at 12:15 AM | Comments (21) | Add Comment
Post contains 593 words, total size 4 kb.

1 The first instinct of most terrorists is to lie, even sometimes to the point of delusion. Baghdad Bob is a great example. I'll wait for the DNA tests.

Posted by: RepJ at January 14, 2006 11:16 AM (kEpN/)

2 Well, we have to see about that. It is not the first time the US goes after the wrong housenumber!

Posted by: Dan at January 14, 2006 12:00 PM (Z2OsI)

3 No Zawahiri, but 30 dead civilians. women and children too. i am sure all their relatives will understand and stand behind the US. I am certain that they will all understand american excpetionalism and realize this was merely a mistake "collateral damage" and stay behind the US and denounce al quaeda. I am sure this policy will not make more terrorists because Bush policy is infallible and not subjecxt to criticism in a free country. ya right...good job making the world a more dangerous place. ernie

Posted by: ernie at January 14, 2006 01:17 PM (X4Dyg)

4 ROFLOL, Improbulus Maximus and Jesusland Carlos are going to have a field day with you. They hate me.

Posted by: George Ramos at January 14, 2006 02:13 PM (5E0ex)

5 Judas, ernie, you're thick. The tribes in this area have hated the US for years. They hate their own government, and they've been sheltering AQ terrorists all along. Didn't you read the articles before commenting? A wanted terrorist attended the funerals, then escaped.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at January 14, 2006 02:57 PM (RHG+K)

6 Oh Bluto, of course, deny reality and keep the ideology intact. I notice how blatantly you must ignore US killing innocents. It just cant register can it? Big brother doesnt want you to SAY you love him,he wants you to MEAN it. Anyway you evade the issue altogether, especially the illegality of US drones invading pakistani air space and firing on civilians...thats called a war crime, for anyone who cares....anyways, pakistans pissed and will the US will lose support, that or Musharaff loses support among his people...just keep fkin everything up an ruining US hegemony...real smart, patriots. ernie

Posted by: ernie at January 14, 2006 04:04 PM (X4Dyg)

7 They don't have a choice. The Pakistani government is fucking with us. They are protecting Osama and Ayman. We are getting sick and tired of it. If Pakistan really tried hard enough, Osama and Ayman would be in jail by now. Pakistan doesn't care. I'm upset at the civilian deaths too. The U.S screwed up this time. Ayman wasn't even there.

Posted by: George Ramos at January 14, 2006 04:10 PM (5E0ex)

8 I don't hate you george, I just despise the air you breath and the space you occupy, and would like for you to watch while I remove your skin.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at January 14, 2006 04:28 PM (0yYS2)

9 "Hegemony"? ernie, you need to stop using words you don't understand. You also need to start making an attempt at a cogent argument. Shrieking insults at everybody just reminds them that you're the ass who pretended to be a Marine.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at January 14, 2006 05:35 PM (RHG+K)

10 ernie, how do you know it's the Americans that bombed Al Qaeda? Possibly it could be the Germans or Italians or the French... Maybe it was the Belgians. ernie, you shouldn't throw stones until you know the facts. It's bad form.

Posted by: Canucklehead at January 14, 2006 05:50 PM (M8IrV)

11 the belgians are flying pilotless drones over pakistan? amazing. hegemony means power and control over others, a form of domination, for your info. and yes, Bush policies are really huritng US hegemony, through debt and loss of allegiance from other nations. it is simple, not a hard idea. ernie

Posted by: ernie at January 14, 2006 06:07 PM (X4Dyg)

12 Wait George, I'm sorry, I had you confused with someone else. Hot Mexican food, cold Mexican beer, and the near presence and dark magic of Mexican girls will do that to me. I was just a little riled up, if you can imagine it, so please accept my apology, as it's not you that I want to skin. Now as for ernie...

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at January 14, 2006 09:38 PM (0yYS2)

13 thanks for more evidence, you were easy to snatch...see you soon tough guy, ernie

Posted by: ernie at January 15, 2006 04:01 AM (X4Dyg)

14 All is forgiven. I'm tired of fighting with you. I am terribly sorry for all I have said. Being 18 years old and dealing with too much homework will do that to you.

Posted by: George Ramos at January 15, 2006 08:41 AM (5E0ex)

15 Heh, now ernie's out looking for me. He'd better be careful or he just might find me.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at January 15, 2006 09:33 AM (0yYS2)

16 actually IM in the other thread about the missile strike, he says he is going to contact law enforcement about "threats" made by you, and he's leaving.

Posted by: dave at January 15, 2006 09:40 AM (CcXvt)

17 Don't you know Dave? Ernie is the FBI. When he's not delivering pizzas, anyway.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at January 16, 2006 09:50 AM (0yYS2)

18 Are you sure its not the NEW YORK TIMES writting all this?

Posted by: sandpiper at January 16, 2006 09:56 AM (uTBPj)

19 Ernie, What right do Pashtun Islamists HAVE TO LIVE? I can see NONE! They are lethal cockroaches. Wake up to reality.

Posted by: leaddog2 at January 16, 2006 11:11 AM (Dg+Be)

20 "No Zawahiri, but 30 dead civilians. women and children too. i am sure all their relatives will understand and stand behind the US." Well let's look at this. When we killed German or Japanese civilians in WWII did we all sit around and moan and groan and knash our teeth wondering if they would understand? On the other hand... when we killed innocent French people during the many bombings of their country they did understand, and do to this day (they may oppose our post WWII policies, but are truely grateful for what we did to save them then). Bottom line, we met the Just War requirements of discrimination and proportionality. Odd, isn't itk that just at that moment in history where we kill fewer civilians than ever before in history, we are criticized all the more fiercely, and by those who

Posted by: Tom the Redhunter at January 17, 2006 10:03 PM (TcuR4)

21 Tom, your Just War theory is laughable. Our dear President has committed the same crimes for 10 Nazis were hung for in 1946. Read the UN Charter, and get a clue. The President is a war criminal.

Posted by: wtmusic at January 21, 2006 05:22 PM (v9gtY)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
27kb generated in CPU 0.0158, elapsed 0.1019 seconds.
118 queries taking 0.0933 seconds, 256 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.