December 09, 2004
Plagiarism and Google
You know how I catch students plagiarizing? Google. Seriously. I just had a colleague e-mail me today how I was able to fail so many while he seemed to never catch it. Just enter a phrase from the paper and 9 times out of ten the number one hit on Google will be the source for the would be cheater.
Comments are disabled.
Post is locked.
Posted by: Rusty at
04:47 PM
| Comments (4)
| Add Comment
Post contains 66 words, total size 1 kb.
1
There's a cool website I go to for that... not that anyone would want to plagiarize me or anthing. www.copyscape.com I think they use the Google engine. It's good for websites especially.
Posted by: Ricky V at December 09, 2004 05:54 PM (AHaCg)
2
I am just wondering why a professor would want to fail so many people, and then seemingly be proud of it. I sure hope the offense is more than one sentence long
Posted by: Chris at December 10, 2004 06:59 AM (tT0wk)
3
another way to do it on Google is to do a sentence like this works+with+words+for+a+song+and+lyrics+too then it will find First that exact phrase then all site with those words spread thru out.
Posted by: Andrea at December 10, 2004 10:06 AM (ywZa8)
4
Chris writes,
I am just wondering why a professor would want to fail so many people, and then seemingly be proud of it. I sure hope the offense is more than one sentence longI'm a high school English teacher. Let me offer a response to this rather myopic post on behalf of the blogmaster.
Teachers don't want to fail their students; we want them to succeed. But plagiarism is not the path to success. Teachers cannot expect that all their students have high standards of honesty regarding their work, and so to must, among other duties, review student work for plagiarism, for the good of the individual student and to maintain a climate of high expectation and fairness for the rest of the class.
The teacher who catches plagiarists and metes out consequences is a conscientious educator; the one who does not either does not care for his students adequately, or, as is common today, is too far behind the technology curve to keep up with the cheaters. If cheaters do not experience negative consequences for their behavior, in ten years they will be cooking books at Enron, committing tax fraud, adultery, or some other public or personal form of cheating. Continued laxity about cheating in school (primary, secondary, and post-secondary) will ultimately weaken the fabric of our society in several places.
That a teacher or professor might seem proud to have caught a plagiarist signals not a self-satisfied pettiness, but a professionalism; the same that a policeman might feel at having stopped a speeder, or a lifeguard at having stopped children from running across a wet and slippery pool deck. Instead of impugning them, we should admire educators who hold their students to a high standard.
The length of the plagiarized material is a distinction of extent, not of kind. Whether slipping in a good turn of phrase in a paper to lend it style and not giving credit to the source out of laziness, or buying whole term papers on-line, the lapse in honesty is the same. Different consequence? Of course. No consequence? Unthinkable.
I just caught a student who plagiarized his whole quarter project by typing a suspect sentence into a search engine. When confronted, he admitted to it, and is now applying himself to his second quarter project knowing that he can't get away with such a breach of the social contract. This time, he may actually learn something from the honest labor. I'm confident he learned something from the plagiarism (it just wasn't the learning I'd assigned). He knows I'll be looking at his work a bit more carefully this time. That sense of accountability will produce a higher quality product. A habit of producing a high quality product will make him more competitive in school and career, and I might venture to say, a better citizen in the bargain.
My screed is done. Professor, may your tribe increase. And to all my teachers who expected me to do my own honest work, caught me when I didn't, and made me feel disappointed in myself when I was caught, thank you.
Posted by: Winsome at December 12, 2004 02:47 AM (DasRG)
19kb generated in CPU 0.0174, elapsed 0.095 seconds.
118 queries taking 0.0869 seconds, 247 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
118 queries taking 0.0869 seconds, 247 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.